Antifragile Circularity

Antifragile Circularity

Tag
Circular Economy
Sustainability
Date created
May 4, 2021
Last tended
Jan 30, 2024
Anti-fragility is a property of systems in which they increase in capability to thrive as a result of stressors, shocks, volatility, noise, mistakes, faults, attacks, or failures. The concept was developed by Nassim Nicholas Taleb in his book, Antifragile, and in technical papers.
💡
Some things benefit from shocks; they thrive and grow when exposed to volatility, randomness, disorder, and stressors and love adventure, risk, and uncertainty. Yet, in spite of the ubiquity of the phenomenon, there is no word for the exact opposite of fragile. Let us call it anti-fragile. Anti-fragility is beyond resilience or robustness. The resilient resists shocks and stays the same; the anti-fragile gets better.

Damocles, the Phoenix & the Hydra

Taleb draws inspiration from ancient anecdotes to illustrate the triad of Fragile, Robust, and Anti-fragile. These stories shed light on the nature of systems and how they respond to stressors. Let's explore the tales of Damocles, the Phoenix, and the Hydra to delve deeper into this concept.
Damocles, a figure dining with a sword precariously suspended over his head, represents fragility. The slightest strain on the string holding the sword will result in his death.
The Phoenix on the other hand, represents robustness. It experiences periodic rebirth from its own ashes, consistently returning to its original state even after enduring significant stressor.
However, it is the Hydra that embodies the essence of anti-fragility. Whenever one head is severed, two grow in its place, demonstrating an inherent resilience and ability to thrive under pressure.
notion image

Anti-fragility in education & human relationships

For any system, a shock disrupts its equilibrium, it is also presenting an opportunity for growth. While the sword hanging over Damocles is a fatal threat, certain shocks can prove beneficial in the evolution of a system. Let's delve into two domains where external inputs and shocks play a pivotal role: Education and Human Relationships.
In education, acquiring new knowledge is a catalyst for the learner’s growth. These nuggets of wisdom can be perceived as shocks, challenging the pre-existing equilibrium of the learner. The most profound of these experiences are the "a-ha" moments, when understanding crystallizes.
notion image
 
Similarly, in human relationships, the vitality of connections between individuals or romantic partners relies on the introduction of novelty. Even the smallest appreciation for new details or shared experiences breathes life into the relationship. These interactions can be viewed as shocks that invigorate the couple or the friendship.
notion image

Growth versus development

The metaphor of the Hydra suggests that growth is the primary mechanism behind the evolution of an anti-fragile system. It is crucial to distinguish between growth and development in this context. When faced with a shock, a couple does not necessarily need to involve a third party to grow stronger through crisis (although it can introduce new dynamics!).
In reality, couples and learners grow through a shared understanding of each other and the subject under study. This deepening comprehension of a system's response to potential shocks can be considered a form of growth, which we can label as development.
Understanding this distinction proves handy when contemplating the decoupling of growth from material consumption within our global economy. Sustainable development can generate a specific kind of growth that transcends finite resources, a development made of understanding. As we continue to explore ourselves and the intricate systems we inhabit, we may find our that an infinite realm of understanding awaits us.
 
Growth of a single element
Growth of a single element
Development of a full system
Development of a full system